Why Is Five Guys So Expensive?

Fresh beef, fries cut in store from whole potatoes, peanut oil, unlimited free toppings, overfilled fry bags and no discounts. Five Guys prices the whole package in, so a burger, fries and drink often costs $16 to $22.

About $12.09 Cheeseburger15 free toppingsNo couponsPeanut oil fries
Short answer: Five Guys costs more because it uses fresh, never frozen beef, cuts fries from whole potatoes in every restaurant and cooks them in peanut oil, includes 15 free toppings, overfills every fry order, and never runs discounts or value menus. Its regular burgers also have two patties, so a Five Guys “regular” is closer to a double at other chains.

Jerry Murrell and his sons opened the first Five Guys in Arlington, Virginia in 1986, and the formula has hardly changed. Instead of competing on price, the chain chose to compete on ingredients and portions, and charge accordingly.

What you are paying for

Cost driver Why it raises prices
Fresh ground beef No freezers in restaurants, so beef is delivered fresh and hand formed
Fries cut in store Whole potatoes are cut daily, which takes more labor than frozen fries
Peanut oil Costs more than the blended oils most chains use
Two patties per regular burger More beef per sandwich than most chains’ standard burger
15 free toppings Grilled onions, mushrooms, jalapenos and more at no charge
Overfilled fries An extra scoop goes in every bag
No discounts No coupons, value menu or loyalty points

How Five Guys compares on price

Chain Cheeseburger Fries
Five Guys About $12.09 (2 patties) About $5.79 Little
Five Guys Little Cheeseburger About $8.69 (1 patty) About $5.79 Little
In-N-Out About $4.35 About $2.75
McDonald’s Quarter Pounder with Cheese About $7 to $8 About $3 to $4
A fairer comparison. A Five Guys Little Cheeseburger is about the same size as a regular burger elsewhere. Ordering Little and sharing fries brings a Five Guys meal much closer to other chains.

How to spend less at Five Guys

Order a Little burger instead of a regular, share one order of fries between two people since every bag is overfilled, and load up on free toppings rather than paying for bacon. Skip the bottled water and ask for a cup of water. A Little Cheeseburger with shared Regular fries comes to around $12 per person.

See every burger, fry and shake price on the Five Guys menu.

Related Questions

Why is Five Guys more expensive than McDonald’s?

Five Guys uses fresh beef, cuts fries in store, cooks in peanut oil, includes free toppings, overfills fries and does not discount. Regular burgers also have two patties.

How much is a meal at Five Guys?

A burger, fries and drink usually costs $16 to $22 depending on the burger and location.

Does Five Guys have coupons or deals?

No. Five Guys does not run coupons, a value menu or a loyalty program.

What is the cheapest thing at Five Guys?

The Veggie Sandwich at about $5.49, then the Grilled Cheese and Little Hamburger.

Is a Little burger at Five Guys small?

No. It has one patty and is about the size of a regular burger at most other chains.

Are Five Guys fries worth it?

Many people think so. They are cut fresh, cooked in peanut oil and overfilled, so a Regular order feeds two.

More on Five Guys

About this guide. USA Food Menu is an independent reference site and is not affiliated with Five Guys Enterprises. Prices are typical and vary by location. See current prices on the Five Guys menu.